Skip to main content

Worked Examples and Optional Depth

Use these cards after the corresponding core teaching. They supply the scenario and a sample response; no external research, new account, real-world contact, or private disclosure is required. The examples are fictional teaching cases, not real measurements, medical guidance, legal rulings, financial advice, or promises of outcomes.

Two kinds of optional work​

  • Supplied practice: the scenario, sample response, and depth question are on this page. Allow about 15–20 minutes for one card, with paper or oral explanation. Read the card before the session; a calculator is optional for arithmetic.
  • Open research prompt: a request to locate or construct missing teaching material, such as outside sources, interview records, or a real-case packet. This is not supplied instruction. A tool activity with complete steps is still supplied instruction, even when an adult must prepare the device or account. An adult must select and verify materials, arrange access, and plan additional time first. Use the supplied card instead when those materials are unavailable.

Choose depth by readiness and interest, not age alone. Learners aged 10–12 can use the core teaching without taking every technical add-on; older-learner work remains optional. The depth questions are not prerequisites for the next core week or criteria for its checkpoint.

How to use a card​

  1. Read the scenario and ask for a reasoned answer.
  2. Let the learner draw, speak, sort, or write using the fictional case.
  3. Compare with the sample: notice the evidence and the limits, not matching wording.
  4. If ready, change the stated assumption using the depth question.
  5. If the core idea is unclear, return to the linked lesson before adding complexity. A private or paper artifact is enough.

Sample responses illustrate reasoning, not scripts to memorize or the only defensible answer to an open choice. They do not require a learner to experience or disclose the situation.

Week 1​

Core lesson: Week 1: Why Groups Need Rules

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional game rule says "No taking another player’s turn." Why might it exist?

Illustrative response: It protects predictable access and fair play. A useful rule names the conduct and purpose, but its fairness still needs checking.

Optional depth: Compare a game rule with a law without assuming identical authority or consequences.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 2​

Core lesson: Week 2: The Shared Stuff Problem

Supplied scenario and question: A shared pretend resource has 12 tokens, and each of three players wants 6. What is the problem?

Illustrative response: Total requested use is 18, exceeding 12. A fair use rule, replenishment plan, and dispute process are needed for this model.

Optional depth: Design two allocation rules and identify who gains or loses under each.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 3​

Core lesson: Week 3: Island Rules Challenge

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional island rule list has a leader but no way to challenge decisions. What is missing?

Illustrative response: A review route and limits on authority. Clear rules alone do not prevent unfair enforcement or exclusion.

Optional depth: Add a process for hearing affected people and changing a rule.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 4​

Core lesson: Week 4: What Makes a Deal?

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional arrangement says "I might help someday." Why is it weaker than a clear deal?

Illustrative response: Who acts, what is promised, and when are unclear. A clear agreement makes expectations visible; actual legal enforceability depends on local rules.

Optional depth: Rewrite it as a fictional promise with parties, task, and time, without calling it a guaranteed enforceable contract.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 5​

Core lesson: Week 5: Clear Yes, New Offer

Supplied scenario and question: Jo offers one hour of help on Saturday; Sam replies "How about Sunday?" Is that a clear yes to the original terms?

Illustrative response: No. It proposes a changed term; the parties need a shared agreement about the day. Silence alone should not be treated as an automatic yes.

Optional depth: Write the final matching terms after both explicitly agree to Sunday.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 6​

Core lesson: Week 6: What Each Person Gives

Supplied scenario and question: In a fictional bargain, Jo supplies paper and Sam prints signs. What does each give?

Illustrative response: Paper and printing work are the exchanged contributions. This illustrates consideration in a simplified common-law model, not a universal test for every legal system.

Optional depth: Distinguish a gift promise from the bargain while leaving actual enforceability to applicable rules.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 7​

Core lesson: Week 7: Writing a Clear Household Agreement

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional household agreement says "Do chores well for money." What needs clarification?

Illustrative response: Task, acceptable completion, timing, compensation, safe conditions, and a review step. Basic care and rights are not wages children must earn.

Optional depth: Draft a safe fictional agreement with one exact task and a way to ask for clarification.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 8​

Core lesson: Week 8: What the Rule Says vs. What the Rule Is For

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional sign says "No wheels on the grass" to protect plants. A wheelchair user needs access. What should be considered?

Illustrative response: The wording and purpose may conflict with access needs. Seek a fair, accessible clarification through the responsible adult or process rather than blindly applying the words.

Optional depth: Write a revised rule that protects plants while respecting access; do not infer actual law from the classroom sign.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 9​

Core lesson: Week 9: Sneaky Gaps in Rules

Supplied scenario and question: A cleanup rule says "Put markers away" but names no place. What loophole or ambiguity appears?

Illustrative response: Someone could put them somewhere nobody can find. Name the destination and the check time so the next use is supported.

Optional depth: Explain why a new wording should govern future conduct rather than inventing a retroactive penalty.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 10​

Core lesson: Week 10: The Ruling Chain

Supplied scenario and question: A prior fictional decision allowed a wheelchair on a path. A later case involves a bicycle. Must the result match?

Illustrative response: Not automatically. Compare relevant facts, purpose, and access needs; a precedent is a reasoned comparison, not a rule that every wheeled object is identical.

Optional depth: Name one relevant similarity and one difference before proposing a result.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 11​

Core lesson: Week 11: Rights Are Shields

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional child breaks a club rule. Does that remove the right to fair treatment?

Illustrative response: No. Rights protect people, including during disagreement or rule-breaking. Any response needs a fair process and proportionate limits.

Optional depth: Separate a conduct consequence from withdrawing safety, dignity, or a chance to be heard.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 12​

Core lesson: Week 12: Don't Put All the Power in One Person

Supplied scenario and question: One fictional leader writes rules, accuses members, and decides every dispute alone. What design change could help?

Illustrative response: Separate roles or add an independent review so the leader’s decisions can be questioned. The change needs actual access and enforcement to work.

Optional depth: Explain why merely naming a reviewer does not guarantee independence or fairness.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 13​

Core lesson: Week 13: My Group Agreement (Micro-Charter)

Supplied scenario and question: Write a fictional group charter with a rule-update method. What belongs beyond a list of rules?

Illustrative response: Purpose, protected rights, who decides, how members participate, how disputes are reviewed, and how changes are agreed.

Optional depth: Add an accessibility route and a clear amendment step; rights are not conditional on agreement with a leader.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 14​

Core lesson: Week 14: Try Tricky What-Ifs

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional charter allows appeals only at a time one member cannot attend. What does stress-testing reveal?

Illustrative response: A process can exist on paper but be inaccessible. Revise the route so the member has a meaningful chance to seek review.

Optional depth: Test another edge case and show the exact wording that changes.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 15​

Core lesson: Week 15: How Fair Disagreements Get Settled

Supplied scenario and question: Two sides disagree over return of supplies. What does a fair hearing need?

Illustrative response: A clear issue, relevant rules, evidence both can inspect, a chance to respond, an impartial decision-maker, and reasons. Court procedures vary by system.

Optional depth: Separate evidence from a character opinion; a confident accusation is not the same as proof.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 16​

Core lesson: Week 16: Everyone Gets a Fair Chance

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional judge reads an accusation but refuses to hear the response. What failed?

Illustrative response: The accused party had no meaningful chance to respond. Fair process matters even when a decision-maker feels sure of the result.

Optional depth: Suggest a remedy that restores the hearing opportunity without promising what the new verdict must be.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 17​

Core lesson: Week 17: Run a Tiny Trial (Mock Trial)

Supplied scenario and question: In the supplied Missing Markers case, Casey returns the markers but leaves the return log blank. Are the two allegations the same?

Illustrative response: No. The return-rule breach is not established under the literal fictional rule; the logging breach is established by the blank log and admission. Judge them separately.

Optional depth: Identify the evidence for each finding and a proportionate, forward-looking correction without importing real criminal-law standards.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.

Week 18​

Core lesson: Week 18: The Decision, the Second Look, and What You Built

Supplied scenario and question: A fictional trial ignores a witness statement the parties never got to see. What could review address?

Illustrative response: A process gap in access and response. A review can correct that gap; it does not guarantee a different factual finding.

Optional depth: Write reasons for a review step and a future rule clarification without applying it retroactively.

Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.